Digital Culture

Every surprise song Taylor Swift has performed on 'The Eras Tour' (so far)

You never know what the mastermind will perform next...
By Elena Cavender  on 
Taylor Swift in a yellow dress standing on stage of The Eras Tour
Every Swiftie wants to know: Which surprise song will she perform next? Credit: Octavio Jones/TAS23/Getty Images

Ten nights of The Eras Tour and still no surprise Reputation songs!

In case you haven't heard yet, Swift adds two surprise songs to her Eras Tour setlist each night, to keep things fresh and fans on their toes. To announce this gimmick on the opening night of the tour Swift said, "The plan, the goal, would be to play different songs every single night and never repeat one. Right? So that when you heard one on this tour, you would know it's the only time that I was going to play it in the acoustic set, unless — caveat — unless I mess it up so badly," she added, "that I have to do it over again in some other city. Send your best wishes towards me that I don't do that."

The thing is: The Eras Tour setlist is already 44 songs deep, so we wouldn't blame her if she lost track (and preferably played "Death By A Thousand Cuts" again). Here are all the surprise songs she's performed so far, which we'll continue to update throughout the tour.

State Farm Stadium in Glendale, Arizona (March 17,2023)

"Mirrorball," Folklore

"Tim McGraw," Taylor Swift

Fans who didn't attend opening night of The Eras Tour seethed with envy when they found out that "Mirrorball" wasn't officially on the setlist. It's one of several Folklore songs that deeply resonates with fans and its live debut was highly anticipated. Before she sang "Mirrorball," she explained her choice: "I was trying to think of sort of an eloquent way to say that I love you and I need your attention all the time, and I came up with 'I'm a mirrorball.'" And her 44-song setlist certainly confirmed that she is indeed "still trying everything / to get you looking at me."

In a tender full-circle moment, Swift performed the song that started it all, "Tim McGraw." "I was thinking about tonight and how special this is, so I thought it might be kind of fun to play the very first song I ever put out," she told the crowd. Some newer fans weren't familiar with her debut single, stirring typical fandom infighting(opens in a new tab). "Tim McGraw" was the only song off her first album, Taylor Swift, performed at night one in Arizona.

State Farm Stadium in Glendale, Arizona (March 18, 2023)

"This Is Me Trying," Folklore

"State Of Grace," Red

Arizona was home to another Folklore heater, "This Is Me Trying." "Mirrorball"'s despondent twin moved fans to tears, and, of course, caused hysteria over the fact she played one of her heaviest hitters on night two. She rounded the surprise portion of the show with a piano ballad rendition of "State Of Grace."

Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas, Nevada (March 24, 2023)

"Our Song," Taylor Swift

"Snow On The Beach," Midnights

Per the request of opener Beabadoobee, Swift played an old classic, "Our Song," at Vegas night one. She introduced the song by saying, "So this is a song I wrote for my ninth grade talent show. It’s called 'Our Song.'" In celebration of the release of Lana Del Rey's album, Did You Know That There’s a Tunnel Under Ocean Blvd, Swift sang "Snow On The Beach," a track that features Del Rey. "Lana Del Rey put out a new album... Guys, it’s so good. You probably already know that, but it’s just extraordinary. I just think she’s the best that we have. I think we need to make it a priority as a group to stream, buy, support this album and this artist," she urged the crowd.

Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas, Nevada (March 25, 2023)

"Cowboy Like Me" (with Marcus Mumford), Evermore

"White Horse," Fearless

Drumroll please: Vegas saw the first surprise guest of The Eras Tour, Marcus Mumford! He joined Swift to perform "Cowboy Like Me." After fans mercilessly teased Swift for not showing Evermore as much love as Folklore, they were delighted to see Evermore get some extra air time. She kept the country vibes going with Fearless track five, "White Horse."

AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas (March 31, 2023)

"Sad Beautiful Tragic," Red

"Ours," Speak Now

Congratulations to Speak Now fans. Swift has now officially performed two tracks off her second album on The Eras Tour. Before she sang "Sad Beautiful Tragic," she declared, "I love this one. When I love a song, I don’t care what anyone says." It should also be noted that Swift switched out "Invisible String" for "The One," on the setlist, something fans paid very close attention to after her breakup with British actor Joe Alwyn was reported.

AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas (April 1, 2023)

"Death By A Thousand Cuts," Lover

"Clean," 1989

Perhaps the most stacked night thus far, Swift played two of her most celebrated and devastating tracks during night two in Arlington: "Death By A Thousand Cuts" and "Clean." After reports of Swift's split from Alwyn made the rounds, fans speculated that performing two of her most iconic heartbreak ballads all but confirmed the couple's breakup.

AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas (April 2, 2023)

"Jump Then Fall," Fearless

"The Lucky One," Red

Texas got two more classics in "Jump Then Fall" and "The Lucky One." She introduced "The Lucky One" — a song rumored to be inspired by one of her heroes, Joni Mitchell — by saying she fell in love with the track all over again when she rerecorded it for Red (Taylor's Version).

Raymond James Stadium in Tampa, Florida (April 13, 2023)

"Speak Now," Speak Now

"Treacherous," Red

Since the breakup news had kinda, sorta been confirmed by sources close to Swift by this point, Swifties were at the edge of their seat to see which songs Swift would perform in Florida. Hoping for clues into Swift and Alwyn's ill-fated romance, fans were disappointed that she didn't sing any of the many songs about Alwyn. However, she did fuel the rumor that Speak Now is the next rerecorded album she'll release. She said, "I've been thinking a lot about one of my albums recently. One of my albums has been on my mind a lot... lots going on in my brain about it. So I thought I might play the title track of that album."

Raymond James Stadium in Tampa, Florida (April 14, 2023)

"The Great War" (with Aaron Dessner), Midnights (3am Edition)

"You're On Your Own, Kid," Midnights

Surprise guest number two! Swift's Folklore, Evermore, and Midnights collaborator Aaron Dessner, of The National, joined Swift for her second night in Tampa. Attendees were blessed with Swift's first live performances of Midnights (3am Edition) faves "The Great War" and track five "You're On Your Own, Kid." She proclaimed that Dessner is her "collaborator version of a soulmate."

Before singing "The Great War," she referenced the fans' own great war against Ticketmaster: "This song really took on a new meaning when you guys made enough jokes about how you trying to get tickets for this tour felt like surviving the great war."

Raymond James Stadium in Tampa, Florida (April 15, 2023)

"Mad Woman" (with Aaron Dessner), Folklore

"Mean," Speak Now

Tampa night three certainly had a theme! Sitting on the piano bench with her bestie Dessner, Swift introduced "Mad Woman," saying, "We wrote this song that I really love because it allowed me to get a lot off my chest, and now we’re gonna sing it for you — because who doesn't love a mad woman?" She followed it up with a song fans could sing along with, too: "Mean."

More in Music, Fandom

Mashable Image
Elena Cavender

Elena is a tech reporter and the resident Gen Z expert at Mashable. She covers TikTok and digital trends. She recently graduated from UC Berkeley with a BA in American History. Email her at [email protected](opens in a new tab) or follow her @ecaviar_(opens in a new tab).

Recommended For You

The best college graduation gifts for life in the real world
By Miller Kern and Cailey Rizzo

These robot vacuums make keeping up with pet hair a much more bearable chore
By Leah Stodart and Andrea Kornstein

More in Life
Google Bard introduces new features for generating and debugging code

Why you should consider going green with your gadgets this Earth Day and every day
By Mashable BrandX and HP

Rihanna, Taylor Swift among the few celebrities paying Twitter to keep their blue checkmarks

Avast show us what to expect In 2023 and how to stay safe

Trending on Mashable

'Wordle' today: Here's the answer, hints for April 21

Dril and other Twitter power users begin campaign to 'Block the Blue' paid checkmarks

How to remove Snapchat's My AI from your Chat feed

The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.
By signing up to the Mashable newsletter you agree to receive electronic communications from Mashable that may sometimes include advertisements or sponsored content.
Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!